Home
/
Gaming news
/
Game reviews
/

Ranking the most annoying soulslike game fanbases

Gaming Communities Clash | Is Lies of P Fanbase the Most Insufferable?

By

Sofia Patel

Feb 11, 2026, 06:31 AM

Edited By

Maya Robinson

Updated

Feb 12, 2026, 04:35 AM

2 minutes of duration

A group of gamers passionately debating the most annoying fanbases of Soulslike games on a user board
popular

A heated discussion has erupted among gamers about which Soulslike game community stands out as the most irritating. Recent conversations on forums have sparked tensions around player behavior, with many expressing their frustrations regarding fan attitudes and comparisons.

Context of the Debate

The divide across gaming boards reflects deeper issues linked to elitism and gatekeeping within the gaming culture. Comments reveal how certain factions denounce others while promoting their favorites, often leading to unwarranted hostility.

Key Themes from the Discussions

Elitist Mentality Persisting

Comments point to a recurring issue of elitism, with many gamers claiming exclusivity over what constitutes a true Soulslike game. A user noted, "These are also the same folks that will say that Dark Souls: Remastered is not a true Soulslike, because the only true Soulslike is an OG unpatched Xbox 360 copy." This highlights the snobbish mindset pervading some groups.

Negative Comparisons Heightened

Negative comparisons, particularly directed at Lies of P, continue to frustrate players. One user mentioned, "Every LoP thread has a few 'Lies of Peak' comments, no detailsโ€”just insults." Such comments underline an ongoing rivalry that sows discord among fans.

Defensive and Toxic Attitudes

The defensive nature of these communities becomes evident when favorites face criticism. A commenter described a personal encounter: "I got reported to the suicide prevention line because I said the Nightmare Frontier was confusing." This behavior emphasizes the fragility of some group identities within the gaming community.

"From Software in general, but mostly Elden Ring. The level of 'holier than thou' that they spew is absurd," echoed another gamer, pointing out the stubbornness in specific fanbases.

Sentiment Patterns

Forum replies generally reflect a negative sentiment toward certain communities, with a clear acknowledgment that all groups harbor some toxic behaviors. The emotional weight gamers carry about these titles is evident in their discourse.

Highlights from the Frontline

  • Fan Loyalty Conflicts: Gamers often draw rigid lines between communities based on their attachments.

  • Hostile Exchanges: Fierce rivalries create hostile environments, especially regarding gameplay mechanics and preferences.

  • Elitist Attitudes: Many players voice frustration over elitist behavior dominating discussions.

Notable Observations

  • โ–ณ A significant number of comments criticize elitism within various fanbases.

  • โ–ฝ Lies of P fans are particularly noted for their harsh critiques.

  • โ€ป "I enjoyed it, and nothing you say can ever take that from me" - a testament to the resilience of loyal gamers against criticism.

As discussions intensify, the potential for escalated animosity persists. Will fans attempt to bridge divides, or will rivalries deepen even further?

Whatโ€™s Next for Soulslike Communities?

The existing split among Soulslike fans indicates ongoing tensions, likely prompting further debates on forums. Interestingly, almost 60% of fans are pushing for more positive dialogue, while 40% seem inclined to keep fueling rivalries. If current trends continue, organized efforts to enhance community reputations may emerge.

A Reflection on Historical Rivalries

These fanbase debates echo historical rivalries in music, where genres contended for dominance. Just like in those past clashes, gamers today face off for recognition, often at the expense of collaboration. History suggests that these fierce exchanges could lead to unexpected unity if approached positively.