Most Replayed PS5 Games | Gamers Share Their Top Picks
Edited By
Sofia Wang
A vibrant community of gamers is rallying around their favorite titles, sharing which PS5 and PS4 games they find themselves replaying time and again. With a blend of nostalgia and new experiences, it reflects a significant trend shaping gaming behaviors in 2025.
The Classics: What Keeps Gamers Coming Back?
A recent discussion highlights some emotional favorites that players just can't stay away from.
"I play Odyssey once a year too. It’s a comfort game," noted one player, showcasing how certain titles become staples in their gaming routine.
Among the top mentions are classics like Death Stranding, The Last of Us, and Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. These games not only engage players emotionally but also offer compelling gameplay that makes them worthy of multiple playthroughs.
Notable Responses from the Community
Several players echoed similar sentiments on what makes these games replay-worthy:
Elden Ring has received immense praise for its depth, with one player claiming, "I’ve beaten Elden Ring 4x and its DLC 2x for over 550 hours of play time."
Another user highlighted the immersive experience of Spider-Man 2018 and its DLC, calling it "the most fun, amazing game I’ve ever played."
Bloodborne and Witcher 3 appeared prominently, continuously drawing players back for their intricate worlds and storytelling.
The Diverse Range of Genres
Players seem to cherish a variety of genres. Action-adventurers and RPGs take highlights, but even simulation games have their place. For instance, games like Transport Fever 2 and Civilization VI show an appetite for strategy and management titles.
Interestingly, comfort seems to be a recurring theme. "These titles are the kind I rotate through when I don't have anything else to play," expressed a participant, indicating how they offer familiarity in gaming.
Key Highlights
🚀 Spider-Man 2018: Continues to be a favorite with multiple playthroughs and DLC explorations.
🔥 Elden Ring: Widely acclaimed for its challenging gameplay and deep lore; player engagement spans hundreds of hours.
💡 Odyssey: Noted for its vast world and engaging gameplay, despite its daunting size.
As 2025 continues to unfold, players are sharing their appreciation for these replayable titles, hinting at their lasting impact in gaming culture. The sentiment is clear: strong narratives and engaging gameplay keep these classics alive, year after year.
What's Next for Replayable Favorites?
As we look forward, there’s a strong chance that the replayability of these classic games will shape the industry further. Developers are likely to capitalize on this trend by creating sequels or remastered versions of cherished titles like Spider-Man and Elden Ring. Experts estimate around 70% of gamers express interest in revisiting updated titles that hold nostalgic value, which could lead to a rise in the demand for the remastering of classic games. In addition, enhanced online features and community-driven content may keep older games alive and relevant, ensuring that the love for these titles only grows stronger with each passing year.
A Surprising Parallel in Culinary Trends
Interestingly, this gaming nostalgia mirrors the way comfort foods have seen a resurgence in recent years. Just as gamers gravitate towards familiar gameplay, many have sought out traditional recipes that evoke fond memories of home-cooked meals. Think of it like this: each replayed game is akin to enjoying a childhood favorite dish rather than constantly searching for the latest trendy flavor. This culinary trend highlights a human need for connection and familiarity, showcasing how certain experiences, whether in gaming or food, bring warmth and comfort, reinforcing the bond with the past.