Gamers Rank 2024 Soulslikes | Controversy Heats Up Over Rankings
April 16, 2025 — A passionate group of players is heatedly debating the ranking of soulslike games, igniting a fierce discussion on forums. Many contributors argue about their favorites, stirring emotions over which titles deserve the top spots.
Context & Significance of the Discussion
The ranking debate comes amid heightened interest in the genre, especially with titles like Lies of P and Khazan gaining acclaim as strong contenders against FromSoftware classics. However, stalwart fans assert that games like Sekiro shouldn't be dismissed.
New opinions have emerged, particularly regarding Strangers of Paradise. One comment observed, "The story isn’t garbage… it’s actually a solid retelling," countering earlier assumptions that it was simply a meme game. Another user asserted that Nioh 2 deserves an S ranking, while the inclusion of Hellpoint and Bleak Faith in the lower tier sparked confusion.
Interestingly, commentary has challenged the classification of several titles as soulslikes altogether. One person questioned the legitimacy of Strangers of Paradise in such lists, stating it feels more like an action RPG with RPG elements instead of a true soulslike. Others have voiced their love for Bleak Faith and expressed disbelief over the exclusion of Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 2. Another noted that "Elden Ring is the king of course," showing its lasting influence in these discussions.
Comment Trends & Community Insights
Three main themes have emerged from the community discussions:
Strong preferences for new titles: Players are eager to embrace recent releases like Khazan and Lies of P, while also standing by classics.
Nostalgic allegiance: Many gamers continue to champion classics like Sekiro, asserting it's a standard that newer entries need to meet.
Diverse perspectives on storytelling: While some believe newer games like Strangers of Paradise add valuable lore, others remain skeptical.
"You need to play Bloodborne and Strangers of Paradise unless you care about story then skip it."
These dialogues reveal a blend of optimism and skepticism, showcasing how gamers are critically engaging with the genre.
Key Insights 📊
◀️ Discussions praise Lies of P as a top contender for best new soulslike game.
❌ Some members express disbelief that Strangers of Paradise qualifies as a true soulslike.
🔄 A mix of skeptical and enthusiastic voices indicates the genre's evolution is both exciting and contentious.
As this story unfolds, the gaming community is set to keep the discussions alive, with members pushing for their favorites while defining what really makes a great soulslike. Stay tuned for updates as these conversations continue to shape the genre's future.