Edited By
Marcus Chen

Amid the excitement surrounding the new Nintendo Switch 2, a growing number of gamers face tough choices over their game collections. Many are asking whether to keep their Switch 1 titles, upgrade to Switch 2 versions, or buy new.
As discussions heat up, one thread stands out. A collector is torn over what to do with their extensive physical game collection. They own every Nintendo title slated for a Switch 2 upgrade, in addition to the expansion pass.
The dilemma? Should they keep the original Switch 1 copies of games like Breath of the Wild or swap them for the new versions? This question echoes through several forums, as players weigh the value of collecting physical copies against the digital upgrade options.
Three major themes have emerged from the discussions around this issue:
Digital vs. Physical: Many players are hesitant about sinking cash into a game they've already bought. โIโm not spending my money buying the same game twice,โ one user insisted. This sentiment resonates strongly with others who are against buying the upgraded versions.
Long-Term Collecting: Others argue for keeping everything due to the unpredictability of digital platforms. Users mentioned risks like the potential shutdown of digital stores, urging collectors to hold on to physical copies for future access.
Upgrade Options: Some players plan to purchase upgrades despite having the expansion pass. Opinions varied on the practicality of keeping both or simply buying a new Switch 2 game.
"Thereโs no right way to collect; just whatever you feel most satisfied with," one commenter stated, reflecting the community's mixed feelings.
Curiously, some worry about the future of certain beloved titles. "Is there any confirmation that all those free upgrade Switch games will even be re-released as Switch 2 versions?" questioned one player, highlighting uncertainty in the community.
With voices split on best practices, an evolving landscape of nostalgia and strategy emerges. Will gamers prioritize their collections, or pivot towards a more digital future?
โณ Many players prefer not to repurchase the same title twice
โฝ There are concerns about digital access to older titles if stores close
โป "Iโll likely go for the digital Upgrade Pack, expecting better access down the line."
Net sentiment in the forums leans towards caution, highlighting a desire to preserve access over merely upgrading. As players continue to navigate this dilemma, the conversation remains vital in shaping future gaming experiences.