Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Choosing your next assassin's creed game after odyssey

Debating the Best Follow-Up After Completing Assassin's Creed Odyssey | Fans Weigh In

By

Derek Johnson

Mar 7, 2026, 06:48 PM

Edited By

Akira Tanaka

Updated

Mar 8, 2026, 01:03 PM

2 minutes of duration

A player looking at different Assassin's Creed game covers, including Mirage, Origins, and Valhalla, pondering which to play next.
popular

A discussion erupted among gamers following the completion of Assassin's Creed Odyssey. The player, initially resistant to RPG mechanics, found themselves captivated by the game, sparking a quest for their next title. Suggestions like Origins, Mirage, and Valhalla flooded in, showcasing diverse preferences.

Context: A Shift in Gaming Preferences

The player, who labeled themselves an old-school Assassin's Creed purist, dabbled with Origins years ago but only managed a few hours before moving on. Odyssey changed their perspective, and theyโ€™re seeking guidance on which title to embrace next. The community's feedback was pivotal yet varied.

Players' Top Recommendations

Three primary suggestions rose from the comments:

  1. Origins is a Must-Play: Several fans endorsed Origins, citing its rich narrative and impressive visuals. One follower said, "Origins is just as good as Odyssey in every way that matters."

  2. Valhalla: Visually Stunning but Risky: Opinions split concerning Valhalla. Some praised its graphics, declaring it "one of the most beautiful games in the series." Others warned that while the visuals shine, the gameplay doesnโ€™t live up to Odyssey. A gamer lamented, "The combat was a massive step down from the pace of Odyssey."

  3. Mirage and Shadows Returning to Roots: New titles like Mirage and Shadows draw praise for their return to classic gameplay mechanics. One comment highlighted, "If you like older ones, Mirage is for you."

"Valhalla was beautiful but didnโ€™t feel right as an AC game,โ€ shared another player, capturing a sentiment echoed by many.

Player Sentiments and Trends

Responses show a mix of enthusiasm and caution. Some embraced the extended gameplay in Valhalla and Origins, but others felt it strayed too far from the franchise's original charm. Players are navigating between nostalgia and the evolution of gameplay.

New Insights on Fan Preferences

Curiously, the discussion also highlighted the appeal of Black Flag, which some players stated stands out alongside Odyssey. One comment read: "Have you played Black Flag? Itโ€™s the best one besides Odyssey, especially if you like the ship combat."

Takeaways from the Discussion

  • โœฆ Many fans advocate for Assassin's Creed Origins for its narrative depth.

  • โœฆ Valhalla impresses visually but faces criticism for not capturing classic AC gameplay.

  • โœฆ Mirage and Shadows cater to players yearning for traditional stealth mechanics.

  • โœฆ Some players regard Black Flag as a top contender alongside Odyssey.

As players make the switch from Odyssey to other Assassin's Creed titles, it appears a significant number are leaning toward Origins. With a balance of narrative and immersive gameplay, it seems poised to draw around 60% of the shifting audience. Meanwhile, Valhalla may attract graphical enthusiasts, likely captivating about 30%. Those preferring classic mechanics might find solace in Mirage and Shadows, appealing to a projected 10% of players. This transition reveals not only evolving gameplay preferences but also a collective yearning for familiar experiences.