Home
/
Gaming news
/
Industry trends
/

Claiming play station games: will you lose your license?

Will You Lose Your License When Claiming PlayStation Games? | Gamers Weigh In

By

Leila Akhtar

Dec 31, 2025, 12:00 PM

Edited By

David Brown

Updated

Dec 31, 2025, 09:22 PM

2 minutes of duration

A player looking at a selection of PlayStation games on a console screen, concerned about game licenses, with a controller in hand.
popular

A growing coalition of gamers is worried about losing their game licenses when transitioning between PlayStation's Extra and Essential subscription tiers. Recent discussions have spotlighted this confusion, especially with reported experiences around specific titles.

Major Concerns Unraveled

Players are still anxious about whether claiming a game on Extra will cause them to lose access when it leaves the Extra library. Recent comments reveal real-life frustrations, particularly with titles like Uncharted Legacy of Thieves Collection, where users noted that they lost their license after upgrading.

"I'm afraid to claim these games by mistake; it would be a shame if PlayStation allows this to happen," stated one concerned player.

Notable Trends from User Feedback

Three key themes emerged from gamers' comments:

  • License Overwrite Frustration: Players worry that claiming titles on Extra could overwrite existing licenses. One noted, "It doesnโ€™t usually allow me to anyway, if I already 'own' it," raising doubts about the consistency of the system.

  • Subscription Doubts: A significant number of players have expressed reluctance to subscribe to Extra due to these licensing fears. "This is the main reason I will not subscribe to Extra," said one participant, reflecting a common hesitance.

  • Clarity on Claims: Many users are calling for better communication about license retention, especially regarding downgrading from Extra to Essential. As one gamer asked, "If I downgrade to Essential from Extra, will I lose all my claimed monthly games?"

The Sentiment of Uncertainty

Players feel strained over potentially losing access to beloved games. "Great question, now I donโ€™t know," shared a participant, indicating widespread uncertainty in the community.

Key Observations

  • ๐Ÿ”น Many users fear losing access when switching between tiers.

  • โš™๏ธ Players demand clearer guidelines from PlayStation on installation and license issues.

  • โ“ Concerns remain about license retention when moving from Extra to Essential.

As discussions heat up among the community, pressure mounts on PlayStation to deliver clear licensing policies. Failure to adequately address these issues could alienate a segment of their audience. Conversely, when transparency is achieved, it may boost subscriptions by assuring players they wonโ€™t lose their games.

Lessons from the Past: Ownership vs. Access

This situation echoes earlier digital music service transitions, where listeners had similar concerns over ownership after moving from CDs to digital formats. Just as music enthusiasts learned to trust streaming services, gamers might adapt if PlayStation offers assurances about license retention. Making game access clear could ultimately reshape how players interact with subscription models, ensuring a smoother experience.