Ranking the Evil Dead Series: Fans Weigh In | Surprising Picks Emerge
Edited By
Clara Evers
A heated debate unfolds as the fandom ranks the Evil Dead series, revealing surprising opinions on the best and worst entries. Fans are divided over the films, the reboot, and even the recent TV show, sparking lively discussions across forums.
The Rankings: A Mixed Bag
Fans are expressing varied thoughts on which Evil Dead content tops the charts. The TV show emerges as a unexpected favorite for some, with one commenter stating it’s a "thing of pure joy." Others rank the films in different orders, indicating strong preferences:
Common Rankings:
Evil Dead 2 (ED2) often stands as the top entry, while the reboot and Evil Dead Rise draw mixed responses.
Ash vs Evil Dead (AvED) is praised for its humor and character depth.
Evil Dead 2 (ED2) often stands as the top entry, while the reboot and Evil Dead Rise draw mixed responses.
Ash vs Evil Dead (AvED) is praised for its humor and character depth.
A notable point of contention is the 2013 reboot. "The remake was good, but missed out on the campy humor," reads one comment, while another called it a "solid and fun film considering the context of that era of horror films."
Fan Sentiments Diverge
The overall mood is split, showcasing a blend of nostalgia and critical observations:
"No Ash, no Evil Dead." - Passionate fan opinion.
Some defend the reboot's direction, arguing it needed a darker tone, while others dismiss it as unoriginal. The response toward Evil Dead Rise is largely negative, with some calling it a "borderline snorefest."
Highlights from Conversations
Deep Character Connection: Many agree that Ash Williams is crucial to what makes the series memorable.
Freshness vs. Nostalgia: Fans debate whether newer entries maintain the original’s charm or fail to innovate.
Comic Relief vs. Horror: Discussions reveal a strong desire for the blend of horror and humor that defined earlier films.
Key Insights
🔼 ED2 emerges as the all-time favorite among fans.
📉 Evil Dead Rise and ED Remake have divided opinions, with many feeling they fell short.
🔄 "The show was hilarious, definitely worth the watch" - highlighting a favorable view among certain fans.
Ending
The Evil Dead franchise continues to evoke passion and debate, with fans eager to rank their favorites. As discussions unfold, one can’t help but wonder: how will future entries challenge these rankings?