Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

In depth rating of the doom games: a gamer's perspective

DOOM Games Ranked | Players Spark Heated Debate Over Ratings

By

Jordan Miles

Jun 13, 2025, 03:49 PM

Edited By

Carlos Gomez

3 minutes of duration

Various characters from the DOOM games showing their unique designs and weapons in an action scene
popular

In the gaming community, discussions around DOOM's ranking have ignited a firestorm, with players split over the placement of various titles. Recent comments reveal passionate opinions on the ranking, particularly about DOOM Eternal, DOOM, and DOOM 2.

Controversial Rankings Ignite Response

A recent ranking by a player led to a mix of support and backlash in various forums. Opinions varied widely, with some praising the original titles while others took issue with perceived injustices placed upon DOOM Eternal, now regarded as a second-tier entry.

Key Opinions on Rankings

  • Support for Original Titles: Many fans defend the original DOOM series, stating, "The iconic monsters of the franchise all came from those games." They argue that these titles remain exceptional, holding their ground against modern games.

  • Mixed Reactions on Eternal: Some players were initially upset to see DOOM Eternal ranked lower, with one comment noting, "I was gonna be angry until I saw there are all S+โ€™s! Rip nโ€™ Tear ๐Ÿค˜" While DOOM Eternal has its loyal fans, others feel it doesn't match the impact of its predecessors.

  • Criticism of DOOM 2: The placement of DOOM 2 sparked fierce debate, with a user exclaiming, "Who puts DOOM 2 at the bottom? IT HAD COOP!" Many assert that its cooperative mode was groundbreaking for its time.

"thereโ€™s still an amazing skill level to how it can be played."

While some welcomed the debate, others dismissed it as hyperbolic, with comments like, "I feel ragebaited." Still, others expressed admiration for the original titles' lasting appeal and simplicity, claiming that there's a reason they remain popular even today.

Sentiment Patterns

The conversation yielded a mix of reactions:

  • Positive feedback centered on the classic games and their lasting enjoyment.

  • Negative sentiment appeared mostly aimed at DOOM Eternal and DOOM 2's ranking.

  • Neutral responses commented on the overall controversial nature of the list and people's differing tastes.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Players highlight the lasting legacy of DOOM and DOOM 2 for iconic creatures and gameplay simplicity.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ Ranking debates showcase playersโ€™ personal connections to these titles, sparking passionate defenses.

  • ๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ "The gameplay is like that of Pac-Man or Mariothereโ€™s a reason people were playing this at the office of all places."

The DOOM series continues to evoke strong feelings from the gaming community, with fans always ready to defend their favorites. As debates rage on, one thing seems certain: the legacy of DOOM is firmly entrenched in gaming history.

What Lies Ahead for DOOM Rankings

As the debate around the DOOM rankings continues, thereโ€™s a strong chance weโ€™ll see more organized discussions in gaming forums and platforms. Experts estimate around 60% of players may engage deeper, creating videos or posts to defend their favorite entries. This could lead to renewed interest in older DOOM titles, prompting players to revisit and even stream these classics, enhancing community ties. With DOOM Eternalโ€™s ranking stirring mixed reactions, further analysis could emerge, possibly leading to a reimagining or a sequel that blends the best elements from both the old and new. The DOOM series may even see an uptick in fan art and memes that reflect ongoing sentiments, fostering a vibrant culture around the brand.

A Surprising Echo in Gaming History

This fervor in ranking debates reminds us of the intense discussions that once surrounded other franchises, like the Mario series after Super Mario Odyssey was released. Players passionately defended their beloved versions while critiquing others. Itโ€™s reminiscent of how music fans argue over which Beatles album reigns supremeโ€”each choice reveals personal connections shaped by nostalgia and experience. Just as fans continue to celebrate different eras of The Beatles, the current debate around DOOM will likely spark new passion for each title, revealing how cultural attachment shapes the way people engage with their favorite games.