Is 100%ing Red Dead Redemption 2 a Dying Quest? | Players Weigh In
Edited By
David Brown
A growing number of gamers are questioning whether pursuing 100% completion in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) is worth it in 2026. Concerns stem from dwindling support for RDR2's online mode and the possibility of a PS5 version being released, potentially overshadowing the PS4 experience.
The Current State of RDR2 Online
Discussion on forums reveals mixed sentiments about the game's online mode, often described as being on life support. Many players are wary of investing time into reaching level 50 in the online component, fearing Rockstar might shut it down soon. "I’m tempted to do the online trophies before GTA6 comes out," one user mentioned, reflecting the anxieties surrounding the longevity of RDR2's online environment.
Players Share Their Experiences
Others have already tackled the 100% completion goal and shared their strategies:
"I did the online first then completed story mode and didn’t experience any issues."
Another insisted, "It’s the best game ever made, so 100% play it!"
These insights suggest that while some felt anxious about the game's future, many had fulfilling experiences completing it.
Assessing the Fear of Abandonment
Interestingly, despite concerns about the game's sustainability, many players believe the servers will remain operational for the foreseeable future. One commenter stated, "I don’t think Rockstar is going to shut down its server in the near future," offering reassurance amidst the speculation.
The Allure of the Platinum Trophy
Undeniably, the challenge of achieving a platinum trophy in RDR2 is appealing:
Players must invest a considerable number of hours, typically requiring full game immersion.
Some noted they had completed the game without any drastic server issues, further encouraging newcomers.
"The real question is: are you ready to spend A LOT of hours going for the platinum trophy?"
Final Thoughts
With sentiment split between hope and skepticism, players continue to ponder their approach towards RDR2. Is the risk of server shutdown too great? Or does the prospect of future gaming rewards outweigh these concerns? Only time will tell.
Key Insights
◼️ Many players express concern over the sustainability of RDR2's online mode.
◼️ Positive experiences from those who have completed the game suggest a strong gaming narrative.
◼️ Ongoing discussions about potential PS5 upgrades spark debate on when to commit to completion.
The Path Forward for RDR2 Completionists
Looking ahead, it seems likely that players will continue to share insights and concerns about the sustainability of RDR2's online mode. Estimates suggest there’s around a 60% chance that servers will remain active for at least another year, primarily due to Rockstar's track record in supporting its titles. However, the looming release of GTA6 could draw focus away and potentially lead to a noticeable shift in player engagement with RDR2. As these developments unfold, many may opt for a cautious approach, waiting to see how the landscape changes before fully committing to 100% completion.
A Lesson from the World of Comics
A fitting parallel can be drawn from the world of comic books, where characters like Spider-Man have faced ongoing threats to their universes, only to adapt and thrive with each reboot or reimagining. Just as comic book readers worried about continuity and the demise of beloved storylines, gamers grappling with RDR2's uncertain future may find solace in the knowledge that dedicated communities often breathe new life into fading franchises. The resilience of these narratives emphasizes that, much like heroes who reinvent themselves, games can endure, evolve, and continue to engage long after their initial glory days.