Inconsistencies in Saints Row 2 Timeline | Timeline Confusion Raises Eyebrows

A curious contradiction emerged in Saints Row 2's storyline, revealing troubling inconsistencies regarding character timelines. Users are questioning the narrative's coherence after discrepancies regarding character jail time and police roles surfaced, putting Volition under scrutiny.

The Context of the Controversy

In the game, the mission "Appointed Defender" introduces significant plot points about the fate of the 3rd Street Saints. Jane Valderamma’s TV report states that Johnny Gat was arrested last year, implying he's been jailed for about 6 to 12 months. However, Gat himself claims he’s been in jail for "2 years and 31 days". This contradiction has raised alarms among fans.

Questioning Character Arcs

Gat’s remarks about Troy also add fuel to the fire. He notes,

"The real kicker is Troy — in a couple of months, he went from undercover cop to CHIEF OF POLICE."

This raises questions, particularly since Troy would have had to juggle his duties as an undercover cop and his sudden ascent within the police force. Given that Gat was in jail for "a couple of years", how could he have attempted to kill Troy if he was already out of the game years prior?

A Potential Misstep by Volition

Fans suspect a crucial error may lie in the claim that the Playa was in a coma for five years; some believe this period might be inflated. One online commenter noted that,

"The judicial system takes a long ass time to get someone into court."

This implies an extended timeline that doesn’t align with the established narrative. Others echoed a sentiment of confusion regarding how Troy could transition roles so rapidly after being exposed.

Behind the Confusion

• The timeline irregularities suggest a possible oversight by Volition.

• Some fans are speculating that Troy's role might have required more time than just a few months post-reveal.

• There’s doubt about whether the Playa actually spent five years in a coma or if a miscalculation was made.

Interestingly, Volition has not addressed these claims directly, leaving many fans scratching their heads. One user pointed out that,

"In the outro we see Troy holding a police badge, suggesting he had already exposed himself and betrayed the gang."

Key Points to Consider

• △ Discrepancies in jail time: Gat's claim contradicts Valderamma's report.

• ▽ Troy's rapid promotion questioned: How could he assume the role of Chief of Police so fast?

• ※ "Gat waiting 3-4 years to kill Troy seems nonsensical" - Comment from a concerned player.

As discussions continue on various forums, the narrative fractures in Saints Row 2 could lead to a reevaluation of the game’s writing and character development. Expect heated debates as more fans weigh in on this timeline debacle.

Next Steps for the Saints Row Narrative

There’s a strong chance that Volition will address these timeline issues in future updates or sequels, as similar backlash can lead to wider scrutiny from fans and critics alike. Experts estimate around a 70% likelihood that the developers will release a patch or an expanded storyline to clarify these discrepancies. Given the competitive landscape of gaming, where narrative coherence is key, Volition may prioritize fan engagement to maintain their reputation and loyalty. Alternatively, if unresolved, these inconsistencies could spark a decline in the franchise's appeal, leading to fewer sales and wider debates among fans regarding the series' overall quality and direction.

Echoes from the Past: The Futility of Time Disputes

In the realm of history, the confusion surrounding the Saints Row timelines parallels the disarray seen during the American Revolution when conflicting accounts and misunderstandings significantly impacted strategic military decisions. Just as players are piecing together character arcs and timelines, so too were generals and soldiers attempting to interpret orders amidst a rapidly changing landscape. This historical disconnect illustrates how crucial clarity and a unified narrative are to the forward momentum, whether comparing revolutions or gaming franchises. Disjointed narratives tend to cloud unity, creating friction and discussions that may often overshadow the original intent.