Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Saints row iv tops saints row the third in fun factor

Saints Row IV vs. Saints Row The Third | The Fun Factor Showdown

By

Rachel Kim

May 26, 2025, 02:07 PM

Edited By

Emily Johnson

Updated

May 27, 2025, 03:05 AM

2 minutes of duration

A character using superpowers in a vibrant Steelport cityscape, showcasing action and excitement.

As the gaming community buzzes with passionate opinions, players are weighing in on the fun factor of Saints Row IV versus Saints Row The Third. A recent surge of comments reveals mixed feelings about gameplay and narrative, with many declaring a preference for the superhero elements found in IV.

Gameplay Dynamics Ignite Controversy

A lively exchange has taken place on user boards, with varying perspectives emerging. Although some feel Saints Row IV is undoubtedly more fun post-game with its array of superpowers, others question the quality of its story. One commenter flatly stated, "The superhero gameplay is all IV has going for it." They argue it lacks narrative depth compared to The Third, which historically has been seen as more cohesive in storytelling.

Superpowers Take Center Stage

Players consistently discuss the engaging nature of superpowers that IV offers. โ€œIf weโ€™re talking about โ€” only the superhero aspect yes, itโ€™s the most fun,โ€ echoed one forum member, supporting the idea that the superpowers in IV enhance the experience considerably.

However, a faction remains loyal to The Third, claiming it captures the essence of Saints Row more effectively. โ€œI enjoyed the writing but the pacing and lack of superpowers made [The Third] less enjoyable,โ€ remarked a contrasting voice in the conversation, highlighting varying reasons for preference.

Themes Emerging from User Feedback

  • Gameplay vs. Narrative: While many praise IV for fun gameplay, others express nostalgia for the storylines in The Third.

  • Mixed Preferences: Some prefer IVโ€™s exhilarating mechanics, while others argue The Third delivers a strong narrative experience.

  • Overall Sentiment: Comments lean towards a positive reception of IV's gameplay, though critiques regarding its plot structure have surfaced.

โ€œI tended to have more fun on the fourth one,โ€ said a community member reflecting on their gaming journey.

Key Insights from User Discussions

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Many advocate for IV's exciting gameplay mechanics over storytelling.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ The dynamic use of superpowers reignites player engagement.

  • โ“ Discussions reveal a complicated love for the franchise, as sentiment reflects both excitement and critique.

Where Does the Series Go from Here?

The conversations suggest a strong desire for future titles to maintain the thrill of gameplay while enhancing storytelling. Could upcoming releases find a balance that satisfies both factions?

The ongoing discussions demonstrate that while Saints Row fans cherish the franchise's roots, there remains a definitive push for evolution that prioritizes fun dynamics, such as the powers showcased in IV. What direction will developers choose, given this feedback? The future promises to be interesting for fans as they anticipate how their preferences will shape the next game iteration.