Home
/
Gaming news
/
Latest game releases
/

Top scary horror games to play on xbox right now

Scary Horror Games on Xbox | Hidden Gems and Fan Favorites

By

Jennifer Lee

Jan 2, 2026, 09:13 AM

2 minutes of duration

A dark, eerie game environment featuring a haunted house and shadows lurking, perfect for horror fans.
popular

As gamers seek thrills, a rising chorus on forums is calling for more genuinely scary titles on the Xbox. With horror enthusiasts expressing their frustrations about recent releases, some are suggesting overlooked titles that deliver the creeps.

Recent Releases Worth Noting

Gamers are diving back into the horror genre with high expectations. A post from a user highlights two recent entries: the Silent Hill 2 remake and Alone in the Dark (2023). These titles certainly have their place, but many want to explore alternatives that offer exceptional scare factors.

What Are Gamers Looking For?

Players are on the hunt for games featuring:

  • Creepy Atmospheres

  • Good Jumpscares

  • Decent Gameplay

While some titles deliver well, others fall short.

Community Recommendations

Comments from fellow gamers have yielded a list of recommendations that spark interest:

  • Routine: Available on Game Pass, it's praised for its atmosphere, though some find the gameplay lacking.

  • Visage and Soma: Noted for their psychological horror elements that keep players on the edge.

  • Dead Space and Alien Isolation: Classics that remain popular for their intense gameplay and jump scares.

One gamer remarked, "Dead Space should be good for you," emphasizing its longstanding reputation for scares. However, caution is advised as another suggested, "Routine you can literally run circles round the enemies," indicating it might not be challenging for everyone.

Sentiment Picks

User sentiment varies:

  • Enthusiasts praise atmospheric games as vital for the genre.

  • Skeptics warn against newer titles that may lack depth.

  • Some cling to classics that have proven effective.

Key Highlights

  • ๐Ÿš€ Routine gains attention but divides opinions on gameplay.

  • ๐Ÿ‘ป Classics like Dead Space still hold strong appeal for horror fans.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "You can literally run circles round the enemies" - A notable critique.

Ending

As the Xbox horror genre explores its depths, it appears thereโ€™s ample room for hidden gems. With the community suggesting a mix of new and familiar titles, thereโ€™s hope that genuinely terrifying experiences await gamers willing to dig deeper.

Eyes on the Horizon

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that the demand for new horror experiences on Xbox will only increase as fans share their thoughts on forums. Developers may respond by experimenting with innovative gameplay mechanics and richer storylines, potentially raising the profile of hidden indie gems. Experts estimate around 60% of studios will pivot to prioritize atmospheric design, focusing on what keeps players engaged. Such a shift in game design can lead to an influx of captivating titles, contrasting sharply with the formulaic blockbusters of the past, which rely heavily on established franchises.

Echoes from the Past

Consider the transformation of the film industry in the late 1990s when horror films like "The Blair Witch Project" broke conventional molds with low-budget creativity. At the time, mainstream horror had become repetitive, leading audiences to crave something fresh. Just as forums now buzz with demands for nuanced and varied horror experiences, that era saw filmmakers innovate to reclaim audience attention. This unexpected shift in approach might mirror whatโ€™s happening now in the gaming sector, suggesting the potential for groundbreaking titles that change the landscape for horror fans all over again.