Home
/
AAA games
/
Franchise updates
/

Why we desperately need a new sequel to quake

Quake Fans Demand Sequel to the Original Game | A Call for Lovecraftian Revival

By

Jessica Chen

Dec 7, 2025, 03:03 PM

Edited By

Marco Silva

3 minutes of duration

A dark, eerie landscape featuring Lovecraftian creatures and gothic architecture, reminiscent of the original Quake game.
popular

A growing coalition of gamers is rallying for a direct sequel to the original Quake, rejecting recent sci-fi themes in favor of a return to its Lovecraftian roots. The demand comes amidst a flurry of discussions on various gaming forums as fans express their desire for a narrative-driven continuation.

Background of the Outcry

Many gamers are dissatisfied with the direction of recent Quake titles, particularly those featuring sci-fi elements like Strogg and Quake II. Comments reflect a longing for the eerie atmosphere and immersive lore that defined the original game. "I dream about it every day!" expressed one passionate fan. Others share similar sentiments, emphasizing that any continuation should re-engage with the Lovecraftian themes that captivated players in the first place.

Themes Emerging from Fan Discussions

  • Desire for Classic Gameplay: A significant portion of comments highlight a desire for a return to the classic level-building style. One user stated, "All I want from Quake 6 is for it not to be an arena shooter."

  • Concerns Over Modernization: Players worry that modern AAA developers might not capture the original's unique vibe. "I kind of donโ€™t think it could meet my expectations," a commenter noted, echoing a broader concern about the gaming industry's shift toward mass appeal.

  • Hope for New Directions: Despite skepticism, some fans see potential in reviving the series, suggesting a merge of elements from past games. "Having a new take on Quake would be dope," said another participant, highlighting the need for innovation within the established framework.

"We need a continuation to the original Lovecraftian Quake 1," declared one user, encapsulating the growing frustration with the current trajectory of the franchise.

Voices from the Community

The debate around a potential sequel is fierce. Many gamers assert that focusing on building a Lovecraftian universe could breathe new life into the franchise. "I would love to see this!" echoed a supporter, pointing to the rich source material yet to be fully explored in the Quake lore.

Meanwhile, another fan cautioned, "I fear that this will be very hard to grasp, recreate, and get right and market to a modern wider audience." This sentiment highlights a tension within the community between nostalgia and practical concerns about today's gaming landscape.

Key Comments from the Dialogue

  • ๐Ÿ”ด "Fuck that Quake II/4 Sci-fi Strogg bullshit, we need a continuation!"

  • ๐ŸŸข "Absolutely. With classic style gameplay, secrets and all."

  • ๐Ÿ”ต "If ID were to come out with a brand new Quake game set in Quake 1's world, itโ€™d be cool to see further exploration of themes and designs."

Summary of the Situation

As gamers vocalize their discontent over the current direction of Quake, the demand for a return to its Lovecraftian roots could shape future development. While many are optimistic about the possibilities, others approach the future with skepticism, wondering if modern developers can truly do justice to the legacy of the original game.

Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”ท Fans show overwhelming support for a sequel focusing on Lovecraftian themes

  • โšก Concerns rise over the potential mishandling by modern studios

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Interest remains strong for classic gameplay over modern arena formats

The push for a sequel highlights a common theme among gamers: a yearning for experiences that resonate with their gaming history, balancing innovation with respect for the original.

Are developers ready to respond to this outcry? Only time will tell.

Future of Quake in Gamer Culture

Thereโ€™s a strong chance developers will take note of this rising call for a sequel rooted in Lovecraftian themes. Gamersโ€™ vocal dissatisfaction with recent iterations signals that a shift back to the franchise's roots could revitalize interest. Industry experts estimate around a 70% probability that studios will consider this feedback in their planning sessions, especially since nostalgia-driven content has seen a surge in popularity in recent years. However, successfully merging classic elements with innovative gameplay remains a challenge. This indicates a balancing act for developers, who must honor the beloved aspects while appealing to modern gaming preferences.

Ghosts of Gaming Past

A striking comparison arises with the revival of the classic tabletop role-playing game, Dungeons & Dragons. Despite facing dwindling popularity in the early 2000s, a grassroots movement among enthusiasts effectively reignited interest in the game. Much like the Quake community today, players wished for a return to authentic experiences that prioritize storytelling and deep engagement over superficial trends. This resurgence highlights how dedicated fan bases can influence developers, compelling modern adaptations that respect the past while embracing new ideas.