Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Sh2 remake for ps5: when does it get scary?

Silent Hill 2 Remake | Gamers Debate Its Scariness

By

Ethan Williams

Jan 27, 2026, 03:11 AM

Edited By

Sofia Wang

2 minutes of duration

A character exploring a dark, eerie environment in a horror game, with spooky shadows and unsettling atmosphere.
popular

A vocal group of players weighs in on the Silent Hill 2 remake, sparking a lively discussion about its fear factor. Content about whether the game lives up to horror expectations post-hospital experience draws mixed reactions from gamers as they push through its unsettling gameplay.

Early Impressions

Many players have noted that the remake, available on PS5, hasnโ€™t provided the expected scares early on. One user remarked, "It's like going through an old ghost train." With the hospital segment just completed, the fear factor, especially for newcomers to the series, seems lacking.

Themes from the Discussion

Feedback on gaming forums highlights three major points:

  • Atmosphere vs. Jump Scares: Some feel that Silent Hill 2 relies more on psychological dread than quick scares. A player stated, "Itโ€™s disturbing. Itโ€™s a slow, creeping dread and psychological horror."

  • Contextual Fear: The setting and context appear vital for experiencing fear. One comment suggests, "Playing in the dark alone enhances the experience." This could influence how players perceive the game's intensity.

  • Look Ahead: Many believe the prison segment is where the real fear begins. "Wait for the Labyrinth," advised one commenter, hinting at upcoming terrifying moments.

Thoughts from the Community

Members expressed varying sentiments:

"If it hasnโ€™t scared you yet, it probably wonโ€™t."

While some are critical of the remake's fear elements, others argue it delivers a psychological experience worth exploring. One player suggested, "You are controlling James Sunderland who is exploring the depths of madness. Enjoy your first playthrough!"

Key Insights

  • ๐Ÿ“… Launch Date: The game has been available for a brief period, leading to contrasting impressions among players.

  • ๐ŸŽฎ Feedback Mix: Players find Silent Hill 2 unsettling rather than outright scary, with many awaiting key sections.

  • โš ๏ธ Location Matters: Gaming environment significantly affects player reactions, with dark, distraction-free settings enhancing horror.

Curiously, while some gamers are disappointed, others are invested in the psychological journey, hoping for a deeper connection as they progress. Will the prison and the labyrinth deliver the scares many are seeking? Time will tell.

What Lies Ahead for Silent Hill 2 Remake?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that as players advance, particularly through the prison and labyrinth segments, theyโ€™ll encounter the true essence of horror that the original was famous for. Experts estimate around 70% of players expect a significant uptick in tension and fear in these later stages. As the game builds on psychological elements, itโ€™s likely that the atmosphere will become thicker, pulling in both veterans and newcomers. Meanwhile, discussions on forums suggest that many are eager for a deeper engagement with the story, which could lead to a reevaluation of their earlier feelings on fear and horror within the remake.

Echoes from the Past: A Comparably Underrated Transformation

In many ways, players today facing the Silent Hill 2 remake are reminiscent of audiences during the initial release of The Blair Witch Project. At first, many were skeptical about its claims of realism and fear, but as viewers began to share personal experiences, the chatter transformed perceptions significantly. Just like a slow burn film that becomes a cultural touchstone, this gameโ€™s haunting atmosphere may take time to resonate fully. The community's role, much like the word-of-mouth buzz surrounding that film, can turn initial indifference into a widespread appreciation for the experienceโ€”all depending on the connection players forge with the unfolding narrative.