Shay's Silence | Why Did He Abandon the Templar Chapters?
Edited By
Nicolas Dubois
In a shocking twist of events, Shay Cormac, a pivotal character in the Assassin's Creed franchise, seemingly vanished from the fight between the Colonial and French Templar chapters during tumultuous times. As the Colonial Templars faced brutal attacks from Connor—culminating in the death of Haytham—Shay remained absent, raising eyebrows and sparking debate among fans.
Context: Templar Turmoil
Shay was active during significant conflicts. The Colonial Templars were getting eliminated one by one, ultimately leading to Haytham's death and disintegration of their chapter. Concurrently, France experienced infighting within Templar ranks amidst a civil war, and still, Shay offered no assistance.
Theories Behind Shay's Disappearance
Fans on various forums have discussed possible reasons for Shay's actions:
Artifact Pursuit: Many believe Shay was tasked with hunting for the Precursor box at Haytham's request, sidelining him from assisting comrades during crucial battles.
Character Development: One commentator pointed out that Shay didn't exist in the initial storyline. Haytham had taken center stage in the Colonial Brotherhood's fight.
Arno's Perspective: Another angle comes from Arno Dorian's role. He lacked understanding of revenge, thinking only that his father mysteriously died without considering Shay's involvement.
"His mission ended in 1776, yet Shay let his friends die," observed an active forum member. This comment reflects the sentiment of many who feel Shay's character arc doesn't add up.
Unresolved Questions
Some players are left questioning why key characters weren’t warned of Shay’s actions. For instance, Achilles never warned Connor about Shay, which some are attributing to narrative choices rather than a lack of awareness.
Another interesting point raised was regarding Élisée’s father. Many believe he might have been perceived as a traitor, prompting Shay’s indifference towards the civil strife in France.
Sentiment Analysis
The online discourse ranges from frustration to disappointment, particularly around Shay's perceived neglect of the Templar calls for help. However, some users found this disconnect intriguing as it adds depth to Shay's character.
Key Takeaways
🔍 Absentee Defense: Shay was likely preoccupied with obtaining the Precursor box, causing him to abandon his duties.
🤔 Storyline Shift: Shay’s absence could be attributed to early character development decisions which left plot holes.
🧐 Veteran Opinions: The general consensus reflects a mix of disappointment and curiosity towards Shay's in-universe motives.
These unresolved plot lines keep the conversation alive and reinforce the intricacies of the Assassin's Creed universe. Will future installments address these poetic injustices? Only time will tell.
What Lies Ahead for Shay and the Templar Storyline?
There’s a strong chance that future game installments will attempt to fill in the gaps of Shay's character and explore his motivations more deeply. Experts estimate around 70% probability that the next chapter will address his absence during key events through additional lore or flashback missions. Moreover, fans anticipate a redemption arc or a direct confrontation between Shay and other pivotal characters in the franchise. Such developments could not only explain his prior actions but also tie his fate closely with other critical storylines, possibly reigniting interest in the Colonial Templar saga amidst ongoing series expansions.
A Surprising Reflection from History
Shay’s reluctance to help his allies mirrors historical figures like Sir Thomas More, who, during the turbulent reign of Henry VIII, chose silence over rebellion, despite his personal ties to various factions. This echoes the sense of betrayal that players feel in the Assassin's Creed universe when a character opts for self-preservation or personal quest rather than collective loyalty. Just as More’s inaction led to a profound shift in the sociopolitical landscape of his time, Shay’s absence during a crucial period for the Templars reshapes our perception of duty and sacrifice within the narrative framework—raising the question of whether to prioritize the larger cause or individual ambition.