Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Should you play alan wake 2 after a frustrating first game?

Alan Wake 2 Sparks Debate | Is Survival Horror the Way Forward?

By

Maya Thompson

Aug 6, 2025, 08:54 AM

Edited By

Maya Robinson

Updated

Aug 7, 2025, 02:54 PM

2 minutes of duration

A character stands in a dark forest holding a flashlight, creating a tense atmosphere in a horror game setting.

As excitement builds for Alan Wake 2, players express mixed emotions about the original game. Some were frustrated by its ending, but a notable faction believes that with the sequel arriving 13 years later, the gameplay improvements could change everything. Will this be a fresh start or another letdown for fans?

Anticipation and Anxiety Surrounding Alan Wake 2

The shifting landscape around Alan Wake 2 raises the question: should players take a break before diving into the sequel? Many gamers are wrapping up the first installment while contemplating if leaving a gap might enhance their experience with the follow-up, especially after their frustrations. Players who disliked the originalโ€™s conclusion, particularly its DLC, have voiced concerns, fearing AW2 might repeat past mistakes.

Gameplay Evolution or Same Old Tricks?

Recent comments suggest that AW2 dramatically leans into survival horror with a slower pace. One player noted, "It is quite a lot more horror survival than the first one. Itโ€™s much bigger, with more characters and larger areas." This shift could remedy the original's action-heavy focus. However, familiar mechanics like "light destroys dark" remain intact. Gamers can expect added mechanics along with a new character storyline that intertwines with Alanโ€™s, amplifying narrative depth.

"If you're looking for a palette cleanser between them, I highly recommend Remedy's other game, Control, which plays totally different but exists in the same world," suggested a user. This highlights a popular opinionโ€”playing Control and its DLC can set the stage for AW2's storyline.

Fans Still Questioning Old Plot Lines

Questions surrounding FBI agent Nightingale's character persist. Many fans want clear insights into his backstory, including his transformation into an alcoholic vigilante post his partnerโ€™s tragic death. According to one gamer, "Nightingale became obsessed with Alan Wake after his partner died, blaming Alan for it all." Such unresolved arcs remain a point of contention for players eager to see narrative clarity in the sequel.

Community Sentiments: Mixed Reviews

The conversation around AW2 captures a divide among players. Some argue itโ€™s a significant improvement, while others see it as a betrayal of the first game. "AW2 is a masterpiece, much better than 1," commented one supporter, yet another stated, "AW1 was a masterpiece. I find 2 too slow and plodding."

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿšจ Alan Wake 2 aims for a deeper survival horror experience.

  • ๐Ÿ‘ฎ Players are eager for clarity on unresolved plots, especially regarding Nightingale.

  • โš  Taking a break between titles allows for a fresh perspective.

Much stands on the horizon for Alan Wake 2. With increased expectations and fears stemming from the past, both seasoned players and newcomers await the release. With a promise of horror-infused storytelling, the new game could either satisfy or frustrate, reshaping fansโ€™ journeys within this chilling universe.