Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Silksong disappointment: is it worth the wait?

Silksong Sparks Mixed Reactions | Gamers Divided Over Gameplay Experience

By

Emily Rodriguez

Sep 28, 2025, 01:21 PM

Edited By

Alex

3 minutes of duration

A player looks frustrated while playing Silksong, showing signs of disappointment with the game's repetitive gameplay and combat mechanics.
popular

A growing wave of players is expressing discontent with Silksong, the highly anticipated sequel to Hollow Knight. While some fans are immersing themselves in the game's world, others feel frustration with its mechanics and gameplay. The release has led to heated debates across fan forums this September, igniting discussions about its overall enjoyment.

The Struggle to Enjoy Silksong

One player summarized their disappointment, stating, "I feel like Iโ€™m spending all my time going back and fighting the exact same bosses or enemy wave rooms over and over again." This sentiment resonates with many who expected a more refined experience after the success of its predecessor.

Interestingly, the game's design has become a point of contention. Players find the healing process tedious and enemy encounters overly repetitive. One user complained, "Every enemy runs away the entire fight, they have massive health pools, and healing takes forever." Such frustrations are common as players grapple with what many call an annoying rather than challenging gameplay.

Mixed Sentiments Among Gamers

The reactions reveal a divide in player experience. While some share similar grievances, others enjoy the game. A contributing comment reads, "Iโ€™ve been having the time of my life with Silksong But I also keep running into gauntlets that give me hell for hours." This reflects that despite troubles, there are engaging aspects that some players appreciate, like boss designs and the atmosphere of the game.

Key Themes From Forums

  • Repetitive Gameplay: Many players echo frustrations regarding the game's enemy encounters and pacing, leading to a repetitive feel.

  • Personal Enjoyment Variability: Gamers are divided; some abandon the game quickly, while others persist despite challenges. One user even highlighted that "Lifeโ€™s too short to play games you donโ€™t enjoy."

  • Adjusting Expectations: A user noted that adjusting oneโ€™s play style could help make the game more enjoyable, stating, "If you arenโ€™t having fun, and donโ€™t want to adjust your play style, drop the game."

The Power of Player Expectations

With high expectations from a beloved predecessor, Silksong sparked conversations about what makes for enjoyable gameplay. As one player articulated, "I wanted to like Hollow Knight so much it just doesnโ€™t click." This perfectly encapsulates the challenge facing many gamers.

The pivotal question remains: Is Silksong a misstep in its delivery, or does it simply cater to a different audience? While not everyone is captivated, there are those who embrace the challenge.

Takeaways on Gamer Reactions

  • ๐Ÿ”น The perception of difficulty varies widely among players.

  • ๐Ÿ”ธ Some hope for future updates to address difficulty balance.

  • ๐Ÿ”ณ "Itโ€™s okay to not enjoy a game. But if you canโ€™t adjust your play style to meet a game's challenges, you might not be โ€˜really good'" - a thought provoking take.

As discussions continue to evolve, it will be worth watching how the community adapts to Silksongโ€™s challenges and whether updates can bridge the gap in player experiences.

The Road Ahead for Silksong

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that upcoming updates for Silksong will focus on balancing gameplay difficulty, based on player feedback from community discussions. Experts estimate around 60% of the player base is advocating for changes to improve the overall experience. With a dedicated team behind the game, itโ€™s likely they will prioritize addressing the issues highlighted by frustrated players who feel stuck in repetitiveness. As the discourse continues, we could see enhancements that satisfy both those who seek challenge and those wanting a smoother playthrough.

A Journey Through Time: Echoes of Past Gaming Shifts

Reflecting on the situation evokes the rise of No Manโ€™s Sky, which faced similar backlash at launch yet later flourished through updates, fundamentally transforming player perceptions. The game's trajectory shows that initial disappointment can evolve into lasting loyalty and appreciation with thoughtful development. Just as explorers once wandered through vast alien worlds, some gamers today may find their way through Silksong's trials, discovering a rewarding experience just beyond their current frustrations.