Playerbase Playoff | A Closer Look at SMITE 1 and 2's Rivalry
Edited By
Tanya Melton
The ongoing debate among gamers centers on whether to return to SMITE or jump into the newly released SMITE 2. As of late December 2025, comments reveal a split in sentiment about the playerbase of each game.
The State of the Playerbase
A recent discussion highlights concerns about the dwindling numbers for SMITE 1, with one user simply stating, "It's mostly gone lol." In stark contrast, sources confirm that SMITE 2 is doing just fine, boasting a playerbase reported to be three times that of the original game. This steady growth comes amid claims of a 10% decline in SMITE 1's playerbase over the past three months, with losses of up to 20% noted over six months.
"SMITE 2 has about triple the playerbase of SMITE 1, and the playerbase is more stable."
"Most people quit SMITE 1."
The Argument for Transition
Despite mixed opinions from the community, many advocate for making the switch to SMITE 2. It appears to be attracting players with various enhancements and ongoing development. With approximately 6,000 daily players in SMITE 2 currently, some argue that this is a better situation than what SMITE 1 ever had.
However, one voice in the conversation warns against overstating the potential of SMITE 2, claiming, "any day during 2018-2020 had 10,000+ players on SMITE 1." Still, many users are gravitating towards the new title. One poster expressed enthusiasm, stating, "I’m in the same camp but I do know that’s controversial SMITE 2 has suckered me in."
Key Observations
🚀 SMITE 1 is losing traction. About 10% drop in playerbase in 3 months.
🔄 SMITE 2 shows positive growth. Claims of stability and an active community.
💬 Community conversations are polarized. Mixed reviews on which game to stick with.
The buzz surrounding SMITE 2 indicates a significant shift in player sentiments. What does this mean for the future of SMITE? As development continues, players await potential spikes in activity linked to full launch announcements, which could drastically change the current dynamics.
With such fierce discussion, one can't help but wonder—will SMITE 1 ever recover?
Future Shifts in Player Dynamics
There's a robust chance that we will see a continued decline in SMITE 1's playerbase as momentum favors SMITE 2. Estimates suggest a potential drop of up to 15% for SMITE 1 within the next quarter if the trend holds. By contrast, SMITE 2 could exceed 8,000 daily players by mid-2026, supported by steady updates and community engagement. This dynamic indicates a shift not just in player preference but also in developer focus, which may lead to further enhancements in SMITE 2 while SMITE 1 risks becoming a legacy title reluctant to change.
Lessons from Gaming's Past
Reflecting on this scenario brings to mind the decline of classic arcade gaming as home consoles surged. Much like the transition to home gaming systems, players are often drawn to platforms that offer consistent updates, engaging content, and a vibrant community. Just as arcades fell into obscurity when players opted for convenience and advancements in technology, SMITE 1 seems to be facing a similar fate. The lesson here underscores the transient nature of player loyalty in gaming, where the latest technology and community can quickly reshape preferences.