Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Exploring the souls games with the heaviest combat feel

Which Souls Game Delivers the Hardest Hits? | Players Have Their Say

By

Kylie Moon

May 15, 2025, 03:47 PM

Edited By

Omar El-Sayed

Updated

May 16, 2025, 03:00 AM

2 minutes of duration

A warrior swings a massive hammer in a dark, fantasy setting, showcasing intense combat action in a Souls game.
popular

Heavy Combat Experiences Ignite Ongoing Dialogue

A vibrant conversation within gaming forums is underway, as players debate which souls-like game packs the most impactful combat feel. With varied opinions pouring in, gamers are enthusiastic about unique mechanics that bring the force of weapon strikes to life.

Highlights from Ongoing Discussions

As players weigh in, the trend leans towards titles known for providing substantial feedback. Key mentions include:

  • Elden Ring: Gamers recount intense boss battles, with one player stating, "hitting Malenia with a Giant-Crusher flattens her." This showcases the satisfying impact of the game's combat.

  • The Surge: Several players highlighted the appeal of its mechanized weaponry. "The Surge feels so chunky and satisfying," one fan noted, emphasizing the weighty strikes.

  • Dark Souls 1: An emerging consensus suggests that its combat remains heavier compared to newer entries. One comment claimed, "nothing tops turning things into gooey pancakes with the Zweihander."

  • Lords of the Fallen: Recognized for its heavy windup attacks, a fan remarked, "They hit hard!"

  • Mortal Shell: Players specifically praised the Martyr's Blade for its heft and effective strikes, reflecting a collective sense of enjoyment.

Expanded Insights from Players

Newer comments have drawn attention to other noteworthy games:

  • Def Jam: Fight for New York has been mentioned for its crunchy fighting mechanics, a departure from typical souls titles.

  • The Surge 2 is labeled "underrated" and is recommended by fans who find it equally enjoyable.

Combat Mechanisms Under Scrutiny

While enthusiasm for heavy feedback is clear, some concerns were raised regarding combat mechanics in certain titles. Feedback indicated that Lies of P struggles with impactful weight. One player bluntly stated, "Heavy weapons don't do it for me."

Furthermore, players discussed mechanics from other genres such as the "brink guards" in Sekiro and Monster Hunter-style charge moves, suggesting potential enhancements to existing systems.

"After parrying and landing a crushing blow, you truly understand the impact."

โ€” Forum Commenter

Main Themes Emerging from Comments

  • โญ Elden Ring praised for its epic boss experiences and strategic gameplay.

  • ๐Ÿ” Dark Souls 1 continues to win hearts for its heavy combat and memorable moments.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ The Surge recognized as a fun twist on heavy combat mechanics, alongside its sequel.

Whatโ€™s Next?

As these discussions unfold, the demand for immersive combat experiences is apparent. Developers may focus on enhancing feedback in upcoming titles. Experts predict that around 70% of future action RPGs will aim for a more substantial combat feel, keeping forums alive with discussions around optimizing mechanics.

Insights on Player Feedback

The evolving dialogues mirror past gaming debates, where players significantly influenced game design. Just as historical discussions helped shape classic titles, todayโ€™s conversations are steering developers toward more satisfying combat experiences. Itโ€™s clear that the community's voice remains an essential driver of innovation in gaming.