Soulslike Games Tier List Controversy | Players React to Rankings
A recent forum thread has reignited discussions around tier rankings of renowned soulslike games. Mixed reactions from players highlight ongoing debates over gameplay quality and boss designs, with some expressing disappointment and others celebrating their favorites.
What Sparked the Debate?
In April 2025, opinions surfaced about various soulslike games, particularly focusing on titles like Elden Ring, Lords of the Fallen, and Lies of P. Players are sharing their rankings, leading to a lively exchange of ideas concerning their preferences.
Key Themes in Discourse
Critique of Top Favorites: While the community generally agrees on Lies of P receiving high praise, some voice differing opinions. One gamer stated, "Great list. Mine would have Lies of P lower."
Mixed Reviews for Classics: Users continue to bring up the criticisms of older titles. A forum participant questioned, "What made the original Lords of the Fallen so bad?"
Support for the New Generation: The excitement is palpable around modern games. Many players have praised Elden Ring, with one remarking, "Finally, I swear this sub was all just hipsters not putting Elden Ring in S tier."
"By definition, how can something be perfect but also not good enough?"
This quote showcases the frustration and confusion around the criteria used for ranking in the community.
Sentiment Overview
The sentiment among players seems divided. While classic games are often criticized, newer releases earn commendations, showing a generational gap in player experiences and preferences.
Final Thoughts
📉 There’s significant backlash about Lords of the Fallen due to its mechanics.
🌟 Players are rallying around modern hits like Lies of P.
🏆 Elden Ring’s absence from high tiers has stirred up strong opinions.
The conversation is expected to continue as players explore the future of the soulslike genre. Their collective opinions will certainly influence perceptions of forthcoming titles.