Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Struggling to save the dung eater in a game quest

Players Torn Over Dung Eater | Miscommunication Sparks New Strategies in Elden Ring

By

Emma Turner

Apr 26, 2026, 10:54 PM

Updated

Apr 28, 2026, 01:57 PM

Snappy read

The Dung Eater character looking distressed, surrounded by dark and gloomy game scenery, while a player character offers help
popular

Confusion persists in the gaming community surrounding the Dung Eater storyline in Elden Ring. Recent forum discussions reveal that many players are attempting different strategies to engage or avoid the character, with some users citing effective methods to save another character, Boggart.

Growing Community Reaction

As the debate rages on, players are exploring various interactions with the Dung Eater. Some have discovered that avoiding purchases from him can open new paths, indicating that decision-making plays a significant role in character fates.

Community Insights

  • A player now suggests, "You can save him; just don't buy any prawns from him and finish the Dung Eater's quest. After that, you'll be able to buy crabs and he'll be safe." This tactical advice adds a new approach to saving Boggart.

  • Another player echoed sentiments of revenge, stating, "You can get revenge by turning Dung Eater into a puppet." This underscores the diverse strategies players are using to navigate the quest.

Sentiment Patterns from Recent Comments

The emotional landscape remains mixed:

  • Strategic: Many are sharing tactical tips to bypass complex interactions.

  • Concerned: Players express frustration over the lack of unique rewards tied to the Dung Eater.

  • Ambivalent: Some continue to regard the character with indifference.

"The Dung Eaterโ€™s fate is just another element in the game. You choose how to interact with him," noted one player.

Key Takeaways

  • โš ๏ธ Players can save Boggart by not engaging in transactions with the Dung Eater first.

  • โœ… Strategies to manipulate the Dung Eaterโ€™s fate are gaining traction in discussions.

  • ๐Ÿ“‰ Many are frustrated with the absence of a specific achievement linked to this character's storyline.

Next Steps for Developers?

As community discussions escalate, the game's developers may want to consider making clarifications through patches. A significant portion of players appears to desire clearer instructions regarding quest mechanics and character outcomes. Could this lead to in-game tutorials addressing these issues?