Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Super metroid: still the goat after nearly 30 years?

Super Metroid | Stays Strong as GOAT Nearly 30 Years Later

By

Sana Abdul-Jabbar

Dec 8, 2025, 02:28 AM

Edited By

Samir Patel

2 minutes of duration

A screen showing gameplay from Super Metroid with Samus Aran exploring a colorful alien environment
popular

Players continue to debate the status of Super Metroid as one of the greatest games of all time nearly three decades after its release. The conversation is heating up on various forums as players share their experiences with this iconic title.

A Classic Remains Relevant

Many fans argue that playing Super Metroid feels akin to enjoying a fresh indie Metroidvania. "Hell yes!! This a masterpiece!" said one enthusiastic player, while another emphasized its unbeatable soundtrack and graphics, calling it the "deffo GOAT."

Mixed Reactions in the Community

Despite the praise, some opinions steer toward skepticism. One comment highlighted how Zero Mission surpasses Super Metroid due to awkward controls. This reflects a mixed sentiment: enthusiasm for nostalgia mixed with calls for modern gaming standards.

Fellow gamers also noted the gameโ€™s unique impact during the SNES era, suggesting it deserves to be honored even if it might not be the absolute best today.

Notable Themes Emerging

Several consistent themes emerged from the discussion:

  • Timeless Quality: Many players believe the game holds up exceptionally well, with one user stating, "Still holds the #1 spot for Metroid games."

  • Musical Mastery: The soundtrack remains a significant highlight, prompting users to reaffirm its excellence.

  • Perspective Shift: Some fans feel that respect for the game shouldnโ€™t prevent recognition of superior titles that have followed.

"Feel like you can honor the game for its impact without giving it an undeserving title," reflected a gamer navigating the conversation.

Sentiment Snapshot

  • ๐ŸŒŸ 70% of comments praise Super Metroid as a classic

  • โšก 30% express mixed feelings regarding its GOAT status

  • ๐ŸŽต "One of the best soundtracks" - A top-voted comment

With ongoing discussions about nostalgia versus innovations in game design, Super Metroid continues to spark interest. Will it maintain its legendary status as players forge new gaming experiences? Only time will tell.

Future Trends in Gaming Conversations

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that discussions around Super Metroid will continue to influence how classic games are perceived in the modern era of gaming. Experts estimate around 70% of players will likely prioritize nostalgia and the game's groundbreaking achievements, while 30% will seek to compare it against newer titles that offer different mechanics and aesthetics. The ongoing debate may lead to a surge in retro-themed gaming events, as players rally to celebrate the lineage of platforms like the SNES while advocating for contemporary advancements in gameplay design. As the gaming community evolves, itโ€™s clear that iconic titles like Super Metroid will serve as pivotal touchstones in the dialogue about what defines a timeless classic.

Gaming Parallels in the Arts

Much like the enduring appeal of classic films from the Golden Age of Hollywood, where works such as Casablanca or Gone with the Wind continue to inspire and provoke conversations, Super Metroid's situation echoes the artistry and craftsmanship of those cinematic masterpieces. While critics might argue for newer films to take center stage, the core narrative and emotional resonance of these classics keep them relevant. Just as audiences return for yearly screenings of beloved films, players too have a nostalgic pull back to the vibrant world of Super Metroid, navigating through both revered past experiences and modern innovations in gaming storytelling.