Home
/
Indie games
/
Upcoming indie titles
/

Team cherry confirms no early reviews for silksong release

Team Cherry's Silence on Review Codes | Controversial Decision Raises Eyebrows

By

Fatima Al-Nasir

Aug 27, 2025, 09:19 AM

Edited By

Maya Robinson

3 minutes of duration

Graphic showing Team Cherry's logo with a game controller, highlighting the announcement about Silksong's release and review timing.

A significant move by Team Cherry has shocked many in the gaming community. The developers of the highly anticipated Silksong have announced they wonโ€™t distribute early review codes, stressing fairness to Kickstarter backers over critics. This decision has led to a mix of acceptance and skepticism among gamers.

Context of the Decision

Team Cherry believes sending out review codes to critics before backers would be unfair. While the intent seems noble, it has sparked heated discussions online. Gamers are weighing in, with a variety of perspectives that reflect a concern over transparency and consumer rights versus trust in the developer's past work.

Community Reactions

The absence of review codes has divided gamers. Some experienced complex feelings:

  • Trust in Developers: "If itโ€™s gonna be any game, itโ€™s Silk Song. Reviews be damned." Many fans express unwavering faith in Team Cherry due to their previous game, Hollow Knight.

  • Red Flags Raised: "Withholding review codes will always feel like a red flag." This sentiment echoes throughout gaming forums, where some feel this approach is anti-consumer.

  • Alternative Suggestions: "Could they not have sent codes for backers at the same time?" Several voices suggest that sending codes simultaneously could have provided balance.

Interestingly, while some players seem willing to wait, others arenโ€™t buying the argument. Support for Team Cherryโ€™s choice coexists with criticism highlighting the company's responsibility to its players.

"Any other company withholding review codes would spark outrage, but Team Cherry is skating by because of their goodwill."

Pricing Speculations and Business Strategies

Discussions have also emerged surrounding the gameโ€™s pricing. Expectations range from $25 to $50, dependent on external factors like partnerships or development financing. Some players feel a $50 price tag might be too high given similar big projects underperformed commercially.

Key Takeaways

  • Major Trust in Team Cherry: Many feel loyal based on past titles.

  • Doubts Persist: Concerns about lack of transparency echoed through user comments.

  • Pricing Talk is Hot: Expected price setting is leaning towards a $30 range.

With the release date on the horizon, gamers remain excited yet anxious. How this strategy will affect sales and trust in Team Cherry remains to be seen. As one gamer put it, "Iโ€™m ready for this game and Iโ€™m getting it day one."

Stay tuned as this developing story unfolds.

The Road Ahead for Silksong

Thereโ€™s a strong probability that Team Cherryโ€™s unique approach will elevate anticipation and ultimately drive early sales, despite the lack of early reviews. Many loyal fans might overlook initial skepticism, inspired by the teamโ€™s successful track record with Hollow Knight. Experts estimate around 70% of the fan base will still purchase Silksong on launch day, fostering confidence that the game's quality will speak for itself. However, if transparency issues persist post-launch, Team Cherry may face fallout in terms of player trust. The dual-edged sword of loyalty versus skepticism will shape this release significantly.

A Fresh Take on Loyalty

Looking back to the late 1970s, the rise of the Apple Computer Company mirrors the situation Team Cherry faces today. Apple initially released the Apple I without extensive external reviews, relying on the trust of early tech enthusiasts who believed in their vision. Just as those early adopters paved the way for Appleโ€™s later success, todayโ€™s Silksong enthusiasts could back Team Cherry's gamble. The parallel underscores how consumer faith can define a product's trajectory, showing that sometimes, a leap of faith pays off spectacularly.