Brigantine Build Controversy | Players Weigh In on Tearing Strategies

A new push for optimal brigantine tearing builds has ignited debate among players. As of May 2025, discussions revolve around whether to prioritize Scurlocks or Urban Great Guns versus grey long nines for effective gameplay. Commentators are weighing the risks versus benefits.

The Divided Opinion

Some players emphasize the need for effective tearing while pointing out the inherent flaw of flooding damage, which conflicts with the brigantine's intended purpose. One participant noted, "I just want a good tearing load out. I like it for cutthroat cargos."

Conversely, others advocate for the grey long nines due to superior tearing capabilities. According to another comment, "Long nines would be a better option since they have tear 3 and piercing g 2." This sentiment showcases a divide in strategy preferences within the player community.

Key Arguments on Tearing Builds

1. Tearing vs. Flooding Damage: Players express concerns that focusing on flooding damage undermines the ship's core design, sparking debates about effectiveness.

2. Long Nines Preference: Some argue that grey long nines, with their ability to ascend and gain double green perks, present a tactical advantage over other options.

3. Modifications Matter: Suggestions for enhancing other flood furniture alongside new tearing builds have emerged, indicating a desire for more variety in gameplay mechanics.

"Adding flood damage to the modification slot would enhance them better"

Community Response

The overall sentiment appears mixed, with a blend of passionate support for different strategies. Players are keen to forge the most effective loadouts, testing limits and expecting results that can shift the power balance in gameplay.

Interesting Insights

• 🔄 Diverse Strategies: Players are exploring multiple build paths to maximize effectiveness.

• 💬 Player Feedback: Continuous feedback rounds out community strategy discussions.

• ⚔️ Gameplay Evolution: New builds may lead to major shifts in competitive play.

As discussions continue and strategies evolve, how will these new tearing builds ultimately affect gameplay? Will the community settle on common tactics, or will this division foster even more creative gameplay options? The game continues to develop, and so does the community's approach to maximizing their brigantine's potential.

Shifting Tides Ahead

There's a strong chance that discussions around brigantine tearing builds will lead to a significant shift in gameplay strategies among players. As various theories emerge, experts estimate around a 60% possibility that the grey long nines will gain more traction in the coming weeks, especially as competitive players look for maximum damage output. The ongoing debates suggest that as these builds are tested in real scenarios, consensus may form around the most effective combinations, potentially reducing the divide within the community. However, the presence of differing opinions might encourage players to experiment further, pushing the boundaries of gameplay even more.

A Nod to the Past

Consider the rise of competitive card games in the early 2000s, where players were torn between unconventional strategies versus established decks. As innovative players tested new approaches, initial resistance gave way to a wave of creativity that reshaped the entire genre. Similar to the brigantine build discussions, this scenario illustrates how community discourse can inspire unexpected strategies, leading to broader shifts in how games are played. Just as legendary deck archetypes emerged from that era, so too might we witness groundbreaking brigantine configurations that elevate competitive play to new heights.