Gaming Debate | Which RPG Should You Play First?
Edited By
Omar El-Sayed
A lively discussion among gamers erupted regarding the best single-player RPG to tackle, sparking opinions on titles like Witcher 3, Elden Ring, and Baldur’s Gate 3. Each game has unique merits, creating a dilemma for players seeking the ultimate experience.
The Context Behind the Dilemma
Typically, choosing between these acclaimed RPGs can ignite passionate debates among fans. The original poster has completed several other high-caliber titles, which sets a benchmark for their next gaming adventure. With mention of favorites like Cyberpunk 2077 and Ghost of Tsushima, expectations are high.
Players Weigh In
The comments reveal a mix of enthusiasm and uncertainty about which title should come first:
Learning Curve: "Elden Ring has a pretty big learning curve" warns one commenter, highlighting the challenges faced by newcomers to action RPGs. Many agreed that Elden Ring is the toughest yet critically acclaimed.
Narrative vs. Gameplay: Some argue that Witcher 3 is the gold standard for storytelling and rich side quests, with one noting, "Witcher 3, imo it is still the best RPG to date."
Diverse Experiences: Another user advises variety: "Curated storytelling and fast action? Witcher. Freedom of play and tactical combat? Baldur's Gate. Cryptic lore and methodical pacing? Elden Ring."
As opinions vary, some prominent voices suggest enjoying all three titles but in specific order to maximize enjoyment. A frequent message echoes that starting with Witcher 3 may ease players into their gaming journey before tackling the others.
"I just bought them all. They are all obviously perfect games" said a fan, emphasizing how highly all three games are regarded.
Sentiments and The Ends
The chat reflects a mostly positive sentiment about all three games, each recognized for its unique strengths—storytelling, tactical gameplay, or challenge.
Key Highlights:
🌟 Witcher 3 is often described as the best RPG, focusing on its story.
⚔️ Elden Ring poses the toughest challenge, recommended for those seeking action.
🎲 Baldur’s Gate 3 stands out for its turn-based tactics and player freedom.
In Summary: As 2025 rolls on, gamers continue to celebrate these masterpieces. Choosing the right one may depend on your current mood or gaming preference, but rest assured, a satisfying adventure awaits in each title.
Game Trends on the Horizon
As the year progresses, gamers can expect a surge in engagement with single-player RPGs. There’s a strong chance that discussions about these titles will intensify, leading to even more community polls and debates on forums and user boards. Experts estimate around 60% of players may opt to start with Witcher 3, given its widely praised narrative and accessibility for newcomers. This choice could prompt developers to focus more on story-driven content in upcoming releases, which might shift the gaming landscape towards prioritizing narrative depth over pure gameplay mechanics. Additionally, as more players experience these iconic games, there's a potential increase in user-generated content such as mods or fan art, further fueling interest in the RPG genre.
A Divergent Path to Understanding
One may recall the late 90s when the introduction of Final Fantasy VII revolutionized JRPGs in the West. Much like today’s discussions on RPGs, back then, players were divided over which game offered the best experience. The eventual preference for Final Fantasy VII over other titles paved the way for storytelling in video games, showcasing how pivotal choices can shape future gaming trends. Just as gamers today debate their next adventure, those early discussions sparked a genre evolution that resonated for years—showing how passionate opinions can lead to significant shifts in gaming culture.