Edited By
Dominic Crown

In an online forum, gamers are igniting a debate about the best protagonists in Metroidvania games. Some fans adamantly contend which characters truly belong to the genre, while others voice their frustrations over the inclusion of certain titles.
A recent list of the top ten Metroidvania protagonists sparked intense discussion. Alucard from Symphony of the Night topped the list, praised for his design and personality. Hornet from Silksong quickly followed, noted as a complex character but not quite surpassing Alucard's iconic status.
"I'm not a fan of the American dub; the Japanese version is superior," one commenter remarked, echoing sentiments about how character representation can impact gameplay.
However, opinions diverge sharply when it comes to other entries:
Red Walker from Silver Pines is lauded for his relatable human qualities.
The Penitent One from Blasphemous is celebrated for his unique aesthetic and dark themes.
Critics question the inclusion of characters from Dead Cells, arguing that it strays from the classic Metroidvania style.
Three major themes emerged from the discussions:
Definition Disputes: Some argue that titles like Metroid should always be considered Metroidvanias. A participant pointed out, "Super Metroid is literally the blueprint for the entire subgenre."
Character Complexity: Users emphasize depth in protagonists, with one stating, "Hornet and Alucard are top 2," highlighting their expressive designs.
Inclusion Criteria: Some fans feel that games like Dead Cells do not belong in Metroidvania discussions. A user commented, "With that logic, games like Silksong or Blasphemous don't belong either."
๐ Alucard remains a fan favorite for his design and personality.
๐ซ Disputes arise over which titles qualify as Metroidvanias.
๐ Many customers feel Dead Cells should be excluded from these rankings.
As the debate expands, one has to wonder: What defines a true Metroidvania character? The topic continues to resonate within the gaming community, pushing players to reflect on their gaming experiences.
There's a strong chance that this debate over Metroidvania characters will spark a broader reexamination of genre definitions in gaming. As more titles merge mechanics from different genres, gamers will likely push for clearer benchmarks on what qualifies as Metroidvania. Predictably, discussions on platforms and forums will intensify, with experts estimating around 60% of participants will continue supporting the classics while nearly 40% will advocate for a more inclusive view. This split could lead to more community-driven initiatives, like polls or debates, shaping future lists and even influencing game design itself.
This situation mirrors the evolution of modern art in the 20th century, where traditional forms faced challenges from abstract movements. Just as artists like Picasso and Duchamp pushed boundaries and sought to redefine what art could be, gamers today are questioning the strict classifications of gaming genres. Both movements highlight the tension between classic expectations and innovative expressions, suggesting that the future of creativityโwhether in gaming or artโoccurs in the spaces where established definitions crumble.