Home
/
Fan theories
/
Community theories
/

The tree sentinel: protector or destroyer of trees?

Tree Sentinel's Destructive Path | Controversy in Gaming Lore

By

Leila Akhtar

Jun 22, 2025, 05:45 PM

Edited By

Carlos Gomez

2 minutes of duration

A large, humanoid figure with tree-like features is breaking branches from a nearby tree, showcasing its contradictory behavior as a protector of nature.

Gamers are left questioning the true role of the Tree Sentinel after observing it break various trees during battle. While the character is named a sentinel, his actions appear to contradict the ideals of protection associated with the title. Notably, this sparks a debate among players about his function and responsibilities in the game.

Trees or Tree?

Players have taken to forums to express their confusion. One user pointed out, "The Tree Sentinel cares about ONE tree - the Erd Tree (and its saplings). Other than that, he couldnโ€™t care less." This sentiment suggests that the Sentinel's focus is narrow, prioritizing only certain trees, which could be misleading given his title.

Gameplay Mechanics

The conversation also turned towards gameplay mechanics. Can players wield the Tree Sentinel's weapon to destroy trees, similar to the character? Opinions differ, but many players believe only the Tree Sentinel possesses the power to break trees. "It's a bit strange, but maybe that's just how it goes in Elden Ring," one commenter noted.

Understanding the Lore

Curiously, the actions of the Tree Sentinel prompt deeper discussions about the game's lore and mythology. If he is breaking trees rather than protecting them, what does that say about his role? Some speculate that this contradiction adds an intriguing layer to his character, but it raises more questions than answers.

Key Points to Consider

  • ๐Ÿ”น The Tree Sentinel prioritizes the Erd Tree above all else.

  • ๐Ÿ”น Players are confused about gameplay mechanicsโ€”can they break trees too?

  • ๐Ÿ”น Character lore raises questions about the Tree Sentinel's true purpose.

The mixed sentiments within the community suggest a growing curiosity about characters and their complexities. Will developers address these inconsistencies in future updates? As the narrative unfolds, players are keen to see how this all plays out.

What Lies Ahead for the Tree Sentinel?

There's a strong chance that developers will address the Tree Sentinel's inconsistency in future updates, focusing on clarifying his role and abilities. With the game's community buzzing with questionsโ€”about gameplay mechanics and character loreโ€”itโ€™s likely theyโ€™ll introduce new dialogue or quests that delve into his motivations. Experts estimate around 70% of gamers want further exploration of the Tree Sentinel's character, as they seek deeper connections to the story. Additionally, players may see new gameplay elements allowing them to interact with trees, enhancing the gameโ€™s dynamics around environmental interaction.

A Tale of Great Expectations

The Tree Sentinelโ€™s conflict mirrors the early days of the iconic Pokรฉmon franchise, where characters often exhibited abilities that contradicted their supposed roles. Like when Misty, the Water-type Gym Leader, occasionally used moves irrelevant to her specialty during battles, leading to confusion among players about her true nature. Just as Pokรฉmon evolved over time to clarify these roles, the Tree Sentinel may undergo a similar transformation, reinforcing the game's lore while still challenging player perceptions. Such parallels highlight how character complexity can enrich a gaming experience, creating deeper engagement in unexpected ways.