Tragic Characters in Gaming | V from Cyberpunk 2077 vs. Venom Snake from MGS5
A fierce debate brews on user boards as players assess who’s the more tragic character—V from Cyberpunk 2077 or Venom Snake from Metal Gear Solid 5. This discussion reveals profound narratives of identity struggle, loss, and manipulation.
Clash of Identities
At the center of this debate is the shared identity crisis both characters endure. V, once thought dead, contends with the challenge of losing their personality while becoming a semblance of a notorious terrorist. One gamer stated, "V made their choices. Bad and good," emphasizing the character's agency in a dire world. In contrast, Venom Snake becomes a victim of circumstance, unable to control his fate as he is manipulated by powerful forces. A commenter highlighted, "Venom had his choices taken away," further underlining his tragic circumstances.
Burden of Pain and Control
Both faces immense suffering. V battles physical pain from cancer while fighting for their identity. Conversely, Venom Snake faces a violent path, committing acts he can't reconcile with his conscience. One user bluntly pointed out, "Venom did so many war crimes just to see the location at the end of the road." Their experiences not only drive their narratives but also prompt players to consider the meaning behind losing oneself to bigger dangers.
Diverging Opinions on Tragedy
Views about who embodies tragedy more profoundly are vivid:
V garners significant sympathy, with many recognizing the uphill battle against overwhelming personal loss. "V… had a hard life. He needs some time to rest," noted a respondent, reflecting popular sentiment.
Support for Venom Snake is equally strong. "Venom is too, the second he got blown up," remarked another player highlighting his dramatic backstory.
Interestingly, the discussion reveals contrasting perceptions of their character arcs. Some comments suggest Venom's singular narrative makes him inherently more tragic. As one player pointed out, "Venom is an actual character and not a mish mash of choose your own adventure like V, making him more tragic because he only has one ending that is definitive."
Key Observations
🔹 V struggles against losing their identity while facing cancer.
🔸 Venom Snake is dominated by external forces, forced into horrific actions.
🔹 Opinions are varied, with passionate supporters for both tragic figures.
Ultimately, both characters illustrate the theme of suffering shaped by their realities. Discussions continue to fuel exploration of what it means to be tragic, inviting players to reflect on the journeys of their beloved characters.
Future Implications for Narrative Exploration
Experts suggest that discussions centered on V and Venom Snake will persist, especially with potential new content for both Cyberpunk 2077 and Metal Gear Solid 5. The release of new DLCs may reignite debates, drawing clear lines among players who support either character's story. As gaming narratives become more intricate, developers are likely to further delve into themes of identity loss and manipulation in future projects.
Historical Echoes in Gaming Narratives
There are significant parallels between these characters and the complex tales of soldiers returning from war, who similarly face identity crises after traumatic experiences. V and Venom Snake's struggles mirror this reality, showcasing the universal quest for redemption and self-recognition amid chaos.