What If Talion's Loyalty Led to Conquest? | Controversial Fan Theories Emerge
A lively debate flares on forums regarding Talion's fate in Middle-earth. What if he wasn't betrayed? New insights suggest he could conquer rather than fall to darkness, generating mixed responses from fans.
Evolving Conversations in the Community
Recent discussions reveal deeper lore implications and player perspectives. Some fans propose that without betrayal, Talion could have teamed up with Celebrimbor, potentially reshaping Middle-earth. As one user stated, "According to Shelob, Sauron gets dominated, and Celebrimbor conquers with no one left to challenge him or the new ring."
This aligns with ongoing themes that challenge the traditional narratives and highlight alternate fates for our heroes.
Key Topics from Recent Comments
Talion's Alternative Fate
Discussion broadens to imagine Talion's future as a ruler. One user implied a shift in power dynamics, noting that without betrayal, Talion could have positioned himself to lead Middle-earth,
"But aren’t Nazgûl just working for Sauron or acting independently?"
Loyalty of Nazgûl
Contrasts arise about the Nazgûl's loyalty versus Celebrimbor’s manipulation, with one comment underscoring their complex nature—"their kindness was oddly wholesome."
The Eltarial Dynamic
Attention turns to Eltarial's absence during pivotal moments. A comment questioned her motives early in the game: "What was stopping her from returning The New Ring and Talion from abandoning the Nazgûl ring?" This highlights the nuances of loyalty and agency in the lore.
"The possibilities of Talion's story remain a compelling debate among fans."
Insights and Takeaways
💡 Talion's loyalty may lead to a world where he conquers rather than falls.
🔍 Nazgûl's role remains ambiguous; they could work independently.
🔗 Eltarial's character prompts questions of loyalty and choice.
As the conversation unfolds, what alternate realities are fan favorites exploring? Join the discussion.