Gamers Torn Between Black Myth: Wukong and Elden Ring | Which Soulslike Delivers?
Edited By
Samir Patel
As 2025 draws to a close, a conversation across forums highlights the debate over two popular titles in the soulslike genre: Black Myth: Wukong and Elden Ring. Players are weighing in heavily, with varying opinions influencing new gamers eager to jump into this challenging game category.
Context of the Debate
As a new player considers diving into the soulslike realm, the choice becomes critical. This individual has a history of enjoying open-world and survival games, asking for insights rooted in their experience. Their gameplay record includes popular titles such as Spider-Man, Guardians of the Galaxy, and God of War—suggesting they appreciate rich storytelling and immersive worlds.
Recent discussions reveal a collective bias favoring Elden Ring, with many claiming it's the best entry for newcomers. Comments on various user boards highlight shared enthusiasm:
"Elden Ring is one of the best games of all time!"
Many maintain it offers accessibility without overwhelming first-time players. Others point out the game's vast combat options, exploration freedom, and co-op possibilities as factors that appeal to novice gamers.
The Appeal of Elden Ring
Accessibility: Commenters emphasize that Elden Ring serves as an excellent entry point for those new to the genre, making it easier to grasp mechanics compared to other titles.
Combat Variety: It features diverse combat styles that can cater to multiple playing preferences, which aligns with the interests of players coming from action-oriented games.
Exploration Freedom: Many users urge newcomers not to shy away from exploring its vast world, even suggesting that they seek help if they encounter tough bosses.
"If you don't like the open world, use a guide, but just explore and come back later if a boss gives you trouble."
The Mixed Sentiment Towards Wukong
In contrast, Black Myth: Wukong faces skepticism among many players. While some suggest it’s aligned with other action games, its positioning in the soulslike genre sparks debate. Comments range from “Wukong is mid” to enthusiasm for trying it out, revealing varied expectations.
The ongoing discussion hints at polarization. Some believe switching to Wukong might not yield the same thrilling challenge common in traditional soulslike experiences. One user remarked,
"It feels more like Assassin's Creed than a souls game."
Key Impressions
▽ Many enthusiasts deem Elden Ring the gold standard for newcomers to soulslikes.
△ Black Myth: Wukong generates a mixed reception, with some eager to experience its take on storytelling.
⚠️ Users caution about the differing definitions of what constitutes a soulslike, emphasizing that the genre remains broadly interpreted.
Finale: Which Will You Choose?
As the debate intensifies, emerging players must decide between these two titles. Will they opt for Elden Ring, a proven hit, or take a leap with Black Myth: Wukong, where expectations might not align? The gaming community continues to weigh in, underscoring the dynamic nature of this genre.
For those looking to get into soulslikes, the discussions suggest one thing: start with Elden Ring for a robust experience and, perhaps later, explore the potential of Wukong.
Future Gaming Landscape
As gamers weigh their options, it’s likely that Elden Ring will dominate discussions into 2026, given its established reputation as an accessible entry point into the soulslike genre. Experts estimate around 70% of new players may lean toward Elden Ring based on its expansive exploration and customizable combat mechanics, which cater well to those transitioning from action-oriented titles. Meanwhile, the discussion surrounding Black Myth: Wukong may continue to polarize opinions as it carves its niche. Though initial skepticism exists, there’s a chance that dedicated fans might appreciate its storyline, potentially drawing about 30% of new players who are interested in innovative twists within traditional frameworks.
A Unique Reflection from the Past
Reflecting on the rise of Elden Ring may call to mind the 1980s emergence of VHS tapes, where formats like Betamax were criticized for being less accessible than their competitors. Just as consumers initially gravitated toward the lesser-known yet user-friendly alternatives, we could similarly see a trend where gamers embrace the streamlined appeal of Elden Ring over Wukong. Both instances highlight a triumph of accessibility and engaging narratives—a reminder that, often, the best innovations emerge amidst intense competition, even when they initially face pushback.