Edited By
Liam Chen

A vibrant discussion is brewing among fans regarding which horror series would thrive as a Telltale-style game. Notable contenders include Scream, Final Destination, Purge, and Alien. Commenters argue passionately about their preferences, eliciting a mix of excitement and skepticism.
Players are enthusiastic about the potential for storytelling in horror gaming, particularly with existing franchises. Key opinions emerged:
Final Destination: The Fear of Fate
Fans are drawn to Final Destination for its unique premiseโevery choice could lead to death, creating nail-biting tension. One commentator succinctly stated, "Like it has this added terror that any and every decision you make could lead to your death."
Scream: The Intrigue of Mystery
Scream garners significant support due to its murder mystery elements. Users see it as a prime fit for the narrative-driven format, allowing gameplay to revolve around classic whodunit scenarios. "The murder mystery aspect that comes with the IP would fit perfectly with how Telltale tellsโฆtales," noted one user.
The Purge: Open World Survival
While some view Purge as an unsuitable cinematic experience, others argue that it could shine in an open-world approach. As one commentator elaborated, it could involve "traveling around and survive. Loot, but zero crafting or building." This mode could challenge players much differently than traditional survival horror games.
"A shame we are far past Telltale's heyday. Scream is the perfect IP for their style."
The mixed sentiments about how these series would perform reveal deeper insights:
Supporters of Final Destination appreciate the thrill of choice and consequence.
Advocates for Scream argue for a fresh story devoid of well-known characters to foster creativity.
Some lean towards Alien and Purge, suggesting these might require different gameplay mechanics to captivate audiences effectively.
๐ก๏ธ Final Destination praised for its decision-based gameplay tension.
๐ญ Scream offers potential for intrigue with its mystery narrative.
๐ซ Purge, while risky, could deliver a unique survival challenge for players.
Though it's uncertain which series would claim the spotlight, it's evident that fans are eager for a blend of story and decisions, reflective of Telltale's legacy.
The conversation continues as the gaming community explores these exciting possibilities.
Thereโs a strong chance audiences could see Scream emerge as the frontrunner for the next big Telltale game. With its rich narrative potential and established fan base, expectations are high that it could dominate the shelf space in horror gaming. Experts estimate around a 65% likelihood for the franchise to be developed, given the interest from fans and the success of adaptations in similar formats. Meanwhile, Final Destination could follow closely due to its gripping decision-making elements, with about a 55% chance of making it to development. Purge could emerge as a dark horse if developers opt for an innovative twist on survival mechanics, holding a lower but still notable 40% probability.
This brewing excitement mirrors the resurgence of point-and-click adventure games in the late 2000s when classics like Monkey Island re-energized the genre with clever storytelling. Just as those titles thrived by blending humor with captivating narratives, todayโs horror series could also redefine player experience by prioritizing story over action. If history teaches us anything, itโs that committed fans can breathe life into any series, much like how nostalgic elements can be reinvigorated in new settings.