Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Choosing the best persona game: your starting guide

The Persona Game Debate | Choosing Your Starting Point

By

Liam Johnson

Apr 2, 2026, 07:50 PM

Updated

Apr 6, 2026, 02:40 PM

2 minutes of duration

A collage of characters from Persona 3 Reload, Persona 4 Golden, and Persona 5 Royal, showcasing the unique art styles and themes of each game.
popular

A surge of excitement is rolling through forums as gamers discuss the best starting point for the beloved Persona series. Some are opting for recent entries, while others advocate for going back in time to the roots of the franchise.

Who's in Favor of Going Back?

Some gamers are advocating for a deeper dive into the series by starting with Persona 1 and then tackling the Persona 2 duology before considering newer titles. One commenter bluntly stated, "I canโ€™t recommend any Persona after that the writing is all bone-achingly awful dogshit." This opinion highlights a divide on preferences within the community.

Current Choices Getting the Most Attention

While many fans still favor the modern favorites, Persona 3 Reload, and Persona 5 Royal, thereโ€™s a range of recommendations to consider. A user emphatically threw their support behind Persona 5 Royal, stating, "You cannot go wrong here, but P5 Royal has my vote." This support reflects a generally positive sentiment towards the gameโ€™s enjoyable mechanics and captivating story.

Interestingly, the initial discussion remains focused on appealing titles like Persona 3 Reload as an excellent starting point. However, the debate on whether gamers should start from the beginning or join in with the latest releases continues to unfold.

Themes Emerging from the Discussions

  • Nostalgia for Early Titles: A substantial number of comments showcase a strong desire for players to explore the Persona series from its inception.

  • Overwhelming Length of Modern Games: The perception that newer entries are excessively long doesnโ€™t sit well with everyone, stirring ideas on game pacing and quality.

  • Enduring Passion for Persona 5 Royal: Many believe Persona 5 Royal to be the pinnacle of the series, often suggesting it's best to play after trying others.

Essential Points to Consider

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Try Persona 3 Reload for a great introduction to the series, balancing nostalgia with modern flair.

  • ๐ŸŽฎ Persona 5 Royal stands out for players who prioritize refined gameplay and gripping mechanics.

  • ๐Ÿ“– Persona 1 and 2 are suggested by a small faction, noting a different experience that some gamers prefer.

As discussions heat up about how newcomers tackle the franchise, itโ€™s clear that preferences differ wildly. Each argument contributes to a vibrant community dynamic, and it remains uncertain where players will head next on their Persona journeys.

The Role of Gaming Communities in Shaping Preferences

Conversations about how to start with the Persona games carry weight within player communities. Supporters of retro titles argue that those essential narrative styles shouldnโ€™t be overlooked, while fans of modern iterations dismiss their concerns. This back-and-forth is reminiscent of earlier gaming eras, merging experiences and shared histories with the desire for new content.

What will young gamers choose as they try to navigate this storied franchise? Only the future will tell.