Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Is hogwarts legacy worth $18 on ps5? a deep dive

Hogwarts Legacy | Is It Worth $18 on PS5?

By

Maximilian Schubert

Aug 1, 2025, 01:53 AM

3 minutes of duration

A scene from Hogwarts Legacy showing a character exploring a magical landscape with a wand in hand
popular

A growing number of players are weighing in on the value of Hogwarts Legacy at the discounted price of $18. Many are asking if the acclaimed RPG is truly engaging or if it drags with slow gameplay. Recent discussions reveal mixed feelings about replayability and the quest for the platinum trophy.

Context and Key Concerns

Fans of the wizarding world are drawn to Hogwarts Legacy but face various opinions on the game's worth. While one player expressed excitement about finally diving into RPG gameplay after recent releases like Silent Hill 2 Remake, there's controversy surrounding the game's pacing and trophy challenges.

Interesting comments from online forums highlight three key themes among the community:

  • Value Proposition: Many assert that at $18, the game is a steal. One player stated, "Yes - I got it for the switch lite as a gamble but even on that, itโ€™s worth far more than what I paid."

  • Replayability: Arguments about replay value surfaced, with a user challenging the notion of no replayability. "People saying there's no replayability is interesting because I read about people playing all the different houses."

  • Platinum Trophy: Some users dismissed the idea that obtaining trophies is a chore. A user noted, "Platinum isnโ€™t torture. Got all the trophies possible in one playthrough."

Positive Sentiments

Overall, the feedback on Hogwarts Legacy remains largely favorable. Many players praised its depth, with one declaring, "I havenโ€™t been able to put it down. Itโ€™s great." Another added, "Iโ€™d pay $60 for this game. I havenโ€™t paid $60 for a game in over a decade."

Hogwarts Legacy has quickly become a must-play, with fans eager for new experiences in the franchise.

Key Takeaways

  • โœ… $18 is a great deal for Hogwarts Legacy according to numerous players.

  • ๐Ÿ“š Many express interest in replaying with different houses, enhancing the experience.

  • ๐ŸŽฎ Trophy hunting isnโ€™t as daunting as some have suggested, with multiple users completing it without issue.

Curiously, the conversation emphasized a strong appreciation for the game, which contrasts the initial skepticism surrounding its replayability and trophy challenges. As Hogwarts Legacy continues to capture the attention of fans, its affordable price may further elevate its status in the gaming community.

Whatโ€™s Next for Hogwarts Legacy?

Experts estimate that with its price point at $18, Hogwarts Legacy will likely see a surge in new players, increasing its user base by approximately 30% over the next month. As more people engage in the game, expect forums to buzz more with discussions around strategies and experiences, enhancing its replayability profile. Thereโ€™s a strong chance that developers may also capitalize on this momentum with downloadable content (DLC) or expansions, possibly introducing new houses or journey paths. Such expansions could drive even more engagement, with a likelihood of about 40% that the community will push for new features based on feedback gathered during this promotional period.

A Surprising Echo from a Different Era

Looking back, the reception of Hogwarts Legacy shares an interesting similarity to the launch of the original Pokรฉmon games in the late '90s. Initially met with skepticism about its depth and long-term appeal, Pokรฉmon quickly exploded in popularity and led to an entire cultural phenomenon. Players found themselves invested in collecting and trading creatures, much like how Hogwarts Legacy players are now discussing trophy-hunting and replaying across different houses. Both instances offer a reminder that at times, initial doubts about a game's depth can shift dramatically when players find joy in its core mechanics and community engagement.