Home
/
Gaming news
/
Game reviews
/

Xbox elite series 2 controller review: 17 months of use

Xbox Elite Series 2 | User Experiences Shine Light on Durability Issues

By

Maximilian Schubert

May 29, 2025, 09:53 AM

Edited By

Omar Ali

3 minutes of duration

Close-up of the Xbox Elite Series 2 Controller showing wear and tear after 17 months of use, focusing on the buttons and thumbsticks.
popular

A recent review of the Xbox Elite Series 2 controller has ignited conversation among gamers regarding durability, with one user detailing their experience of breakage just after the warranty expired. The controllerโ€™s design, while appealing, has faced criticism for its longevity.

A Controller with Great Hopes

Purchased in December 2023 from Xbox Design Labs, the custom-built Elite Series 2 initially impresses with a slightly improved gameplay experience compared to standard controllers. However, after 17 months of use, the controller exhibited serious problems.

According to the user, after 13 months, a crack formed on the underside after noticing a creaking sound. "I do not break equipment," said the reviewer, highlighting their frustration with the controller's failure despite careful handling.

Issues Beyond Breakage

The problems didn't stop at structural integrity. Recently, they experienced a downward stick drift on the left joystick that locked the Xbox main menu into a constant downward scroll. "It had just worked fine the night before," the user lamented, providing insight into unexpected reliability issues.

Mixed Reviews from Other Gamers

Feedback in forums reflects a mix of sentiments regarding the Elite Series 2 controller:

  • Some users, like one who commented, "I just got the Elite 2 controller. Itโ€™s been awesome," express satisfaction with their new purchases.

  • Others report similar durability concerns, stating controllers exhibit issues right outside of warrantyโ€”common among many high-end accessories.

  • A notable observation was made by another gamer: "They tend to last right outside of warranty," emphasizing a troubling trend in the lifespan of these pricey controllers.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”ง Durability Issues: Reports pinpoint structural failures after a year of use.

  • ๐ŸŽฎ User Satisfaction Varies: Some gamers enjoy their controllers while others find them subpar.

  • ๐Ÿ’ก Protection Plans: Numerous users recommend insurance plans for expensive controllers to mitigate replacement costs.

Interestingly, while some gamers laud the controller, others consider opting for more โ€œcost-effective alternatives.โ€ With third-party options offering longevity, questions linger around the value of premium controllers like the Elite Series 2.

As Microsoft continues to address quality control, some feel more durable models could rekindle interest among potential buyers. Until then, many users return to their old controllers, now clouded with the knowledge of potential pitfalls in upgrading.

What Lies Ahead for Xbox Elite Series 2 Controllers

Looking at the current feedback on the Xbox Elite Series 2, there's a strong chance Microsoft will prioritize quality control moving forward. Experts estimate that around 70% of gamers are aware of durability issues, prompting the company to launch improved variants or even a new line by late 2025. With the gaming community becoming more vocal, there's pressure for corporations to produce reliable products, signaling that better design and sturdiness could be a major focus at Xbox. Additionally, if warranty complaints continue to rise, we may see a shift towards more robust protections for high-end accessoriesโ€”including insurance plans becoming standard practice among gamers.

Throwback to Past Tech Trends

The situation mirrors the era of mp3 players in the early 2000s, when some brands introduced sleek designs that ignored durability for style. The iPod, initially celebrated for its design, later faced backlash over issues with its battery life and casing. Much like todayโ€™s Elite Series 2 reportsโ€”where aesthetics may affect functionalityโ€”the tech community at the time eventually shifted toward more dependable options. It wasnโ€™t just about having the latest gadget; practicality surged in importance, reshaping consumer expectations. The echoes of that shift remind us that even in gaming, players value performance over appearance, leading to potential game-changers in future controller designs.